Since 2005 or so, I have been listening to music on my Mac by means of an Altec Lansing FX6021 speaker system with two stereo audio system and a subwoofer. The sound has been glorious, and I’ve appreciated having a devoted controller for energy and quantity – it makes it simpler to show down the sound or regulate the quantity than to make use of keyboard shortcuts or a graphical interface. Alas, one thing within the controller fails just lately, rendering the controls inoperable and the sound cuts off or disappears altogether. After some troubleshooting, I decided that substitute was most likely the higher a part of heroics and sought (and acquired) suggestions on TidBITS speak.

Nevertheless, I nonetheless need to hearken to music whereas I am engaged on all of the ideas. I work on a 27-inch iMac with a 27-inch Thunderbolt show, and each have good stereo audio system. Once I tried to make use of both one, nevertheless, the sound felt unbalanced. I stand just about proper between them, so routing the audio by means of the iMac (which sits on the proper facet of my desk) got here in from my proper, whereas sending it by means of the Thunderbolt show went to my left. I needed to discover a option to stability the sign between each pairs for extra correct stereo sound.

With ideas of HomePod stereo pairs working by means of my head, I did a little analysis and found that Apple has lengthy supplied a option to mix a number of audio output units right into a single vacation spot. By combining the audio system in my iMac and Thunderbolt Show, I can once more get sound out of either side of my desk equally. You should use this functionality to play the identical audio by means of your Mac and a set of linked audio system, or to configure a 5:1 or 7:1 surround-sound system. Sadly, you possibly can’t embody AirPlay audio system just like the HomePod in that blend; Extra on that later.

Create a multi-output machine

The trick to creating this mixture audio magic occur is the Audio MIDI Setup app, which you will discover within the Utilities folder contained in the Functions folder. I will not faux to grasp what it does – I am not an audio man – however connecting a number of audio output units to a single vacation spot is comparatively easy, albeit with quite a lot of gotchas.

(Expensive Apple, you would possibly need to replace the audio MIDI setup in order that its interface is in sync along with your company model information, which opposes the time period “grasp”.

Observe these steps to create a multi-output machine:

  1. In Audio MIDI Setup, click on the + button on the backside of the checklist of audio units and choose Create multi-output machine.
  2. Click on the Use checkbox for every audio machine you need to mix.
    Audio MIDI setup showing a multi-output device
  3. So far as I can inform, it does not matter which machine is chosen within the Grasp Machine pop-up menu, though the Drift Correction checkbox will routinely be chosen for units aside from the grasp machine.
  4. Until you have got a DAC (Digital-to-Analog Converter) that gives a better pattern price, go away the Pattern Fee pop-up menu at 44.1 kHz. When you’ve got a DAC, select the very best pattern price at which you’ll be able to hear the audio high quality distinction.
  5. It’s best to see a small speaker icon to the proper and beneath the Multi-Output Machine entry within the checklist. If not, Management-click the multi-output machine and choose Use this machine for sound output. (This has the identical impact as deciding on it for Output in System Preferences > Sound > Output.)
  6. To be sure to do not blast your ears with too loud music while you use your multi-output machine for the primary time, click on the entry on your grasp machine within the checklist and choose Channels within the Quantity pane. Alter the grasp slider to low sufficient. , Repeat this course of along with your secondary output machine—as you possibly can see beneath, my Thunderbolt show has separate sliders for Entrance Left and Entrance Proper.
    Adjusting Volume in Audio MIDI Setup
  7. Swap to the Music app and begin taking part in a observe you are accustomed to, ideally one with good stereo separation. I All the time Default to Dire Straits brothers in Arms Album—This was additionally my first CD within the late Nineteen Eighties.
  8. Again within the audio MIDI setup, work backwards and forwards between the completely different output units to set the quantity to an excellent degree and regulate the left/proper stability. The way you do that could fluctuate by machine. For my iMac’s audio system, there is a stability slider that I’ve moved to the proper in favor of its right-hand speaker. For the Thunderbolt Show, there is no stability slider, so I needed to flip up the entrance left quantity to favor its left-hand speaker. As a result of the iMac’s left speaker and the Thunderbolt Show’s proper speaker sit proper in entrance of me and work collectively, I put loads of emphasis on them.
    Adjusting Balance in Audio MIDI Setup
  9. Notice the Mute checkbox to the left of the quantity slider. I discovered it extraordinarily useful to mute one set of audio system after which mute the opposite as I labored to set the quantity and stability correctly. (For a extra correct manner of figuring out the best quantity, you should use a sound stress degree app like Decibel X to measure the sound from every speaker in flip.)
  10. For those who’re configuring a surround-sound system with a number of audio system, click on the Configure Audio system button to carry up an interface for connecting audio system to channels. I haven’t got the {hardware} to check it, so I ? button within the Configure Speaker Interface for extra info.
    Configuring Speakers in Audio MIDI Setup
  11. Lastly, if you would like to see a extra descriptive identify, click on the identify of the Multi-Output Machine entry and edit it as desired.

You are executed, however it is time to examine the nexus.

Gotcha #1: No Quantity Management for A number of-Output Gadgets

Sadly, as you will shortly discover, a multiple-output machine has no grasp quantity management within the Sounds choice pane, the Quantity menu bar merchandise does not work, and macOS’ built-in keyboard shortcuts are disabled. For sure, it is a downside, though it has many options.

  • Sound Supply: The very best answer to this downside is Rogue Amoeba (a latest TidBITS sponsor)’s Soundsource utility, which gives menu bar entry for system units (together with multi-output units), permitting you to manage the quantity on a per-app foundation. You’ll be able to add, and add results to, any machine or app. Even higher, in the event you take a fast journey to Soundsource > Preferences > Audio, you possibly can choose the Tremendous Quantity keys, which allows the system quantity keys to manage in any other case unneeded audio units. The soundsource prices $39, although TidBITS members can save 20%, dropping the value to $31.20.
    Soundsource interface and preferences
  • music: Though I at all times consider controlling the quantity on the system degree, I used to be reminded that the Music app has its personal quantity controls and keyboard shortcuts. For those who solely play audio by means of Music, you possibly can handle the quantity solely throughout the app itself.
  • Keyboard Maestro: It is at all times price making an attempt to troubleshoot issues with Ladder Software program’s Keyboard Maestro, though on this case, it is not an entire answer. Though Keyboard Maestro has actions that may increase, decrease, and mute the system quantity, these actions will not work except you even have the soundsource’s Tremendous Quantity keys enabled. Keyboard Maestro’s actions are more practical for controlling quantity and playback within the Music app. With them, you possibly can create macros that assist you to improve or lower the quantity of the at present taking part in music, or just pause playback. Keyboard Maestro prices $36, and TidBITS members can save 20%, bringing the value to $28.80.
    keyboard maestro volume macro
  • Increase 3D: I’m fairly keen on the 3D sound results supplied by Increase 3D from World Delight (one other latest TidBITS sponsor). It presents some options that intersect with this downside, although it is not solely passable. Most notably, the Increase 3D’s menu bar interface has quantity controls, and you may assign hotkeys to manage it inside one other app. Plus, the Increase allows per-app quantity settings just like the 3D soundsource. The issue is that the primary quantity management does not flip to zero, rendering it ineffective as a mute possibility. The per-app quantity drops to zero, so you possibly can mute a specific app, but it surely requires an additional click on and slider manipulation—there is no hotkey for per-app quantity. Increase 3D prices $14.99, and TidBITS members can save 25%, bringing the value to $11.24.
    boom 3d volume control

In truth, since I’ve all these apps, I’m going to make use of all of them. Soundsource gives a pleasant dashboard for all sound-related actions on my Mac and allows system quantity controls, Keyboard Maestro lets me management audio from the keyboard, and Increase 3D amplifies the music.

Gotcha #2: No AirPlay in Multi-Output Gadgets

You’ll be able to add an AirPlay machine to Audio MIDI Setup by clicking the + button and deciding on it from the Join AirPlay machine menu. As soon as you’ve got executed that, an AirPlay output turns into accessible for choice as a part of a multi-output machine. Sadly, as quickly as you make the multi-output machine the default audio output, the AirPlay machine disappears, and no audio is shipped to it by the multi-output machine.

Nevertheless, there’s a answer, not less than for these utilizing the Music app. For those who click on the AirPlay button within the Music toolbar, you possibly can choose a number of AirPlay locations and set their quantity independently. The pc makes use of no matter audio output is chosen within the Vacation spot Sound choice pane, so on this case, that will be my multi-output machine. Once I paired it with the bed room HomePod, which I had briefly borrowed, my workplace was crammed with sound.

Multiple Speakers in Music App

There are two downsides to this workaround:

  • It solely works in music. It could sound apparent, however if you wish to, say, hearken to music on YouTube by way of Safari, you are out of luck.
  • The one quantity slider controlling all chosen audio system is within the Music app itself. Chances are you’ll end up, like me, fully confused when different apps appear to manage the quantity with none considerable distinction. (The HomePod was so loud I may barely inform that my iMac and Thunderbolt Show audio system weren’t contributing to the general sound.)

The answer to these issues is the evil amoeba’s Airfoil. It could ship audio from any Mac app — or all system audio — to AirPlay and non-AirPlay audio units, working across the music limitation. You can too independently select by means of which audio system the “laptop” audio is performed. And it gives keyboard shortcuts to manage the quantity and mute the audio. Airfoil prices $29, or $23.20 for TidBITS members after 20% off.

Airfoil interface and preferences

on speaker analysis

Though I’ve had loads of enjoyable working by means of all of the implications of including audio system to my iMac and Thunderbolt Show, once I introduced the HomePod into the combo, it was instantly clear that it may produce very top quality audio by itself. does, particularly when it comes to bass. This implies that hacking my audio will not get rid of the necessity to change my Altec Lansing FX6201 audio system, maybe with one thing that has a subwoofer. So it is time to cease writing and begin researching all of the suggestions in TidBITS Speak (and when you’ve got any others, please contribute them).

Supply hyperlink